Retail Leadership Rule #3: Don’t be Buffaloed by Experts and Elites

Memorial Day is a sacred occasion—one dedicated to honoring those who have paid the ultimate price in service to our country. These brave men and women gave their lives so that we could live in freedom. While Veterans Day serves to honor all veterans, Memorial Day is specifically for those who have died in combat.

General Colin Powell, who passed away in 2021, did not die on the battlefield, but his leadership lessons are still deeply relevant on this day of remembrance. Memorial Day isn’t technically for him, but I can’t help but think of him and others who have impacted my life, regardless of the circumstances of their death. It may feel like a bit of “cheating,” but in my view, it’s okay to extend the holiday a little further.

Honoring sacrifice: A Memorial Day reflection

Today, I think about the countless young men and women who swore an oath, deployed to foreign lands, and never returned. It’s a type of sacrifice that few can truly understand unless they’ve experienced it firsthand. To all those who have fallen in service to this country, I offer my deepest respect. May they rest in peace, and may their families and loved ones find solace.

As I wrap up my mini-series on Colin Powell’s leadership principles, I reflect on two of my favorites—principles that resonate deeply within the retail world. In previous posts, we explored Powell’s focus on Perpetual Optimism and Focusing on the Details. This week, I’m closing out the series with Leadership Lesson #3: Don’t be Buffaloed by Experts and Elites.

General Powell’s leadership lesson #3

“Don’t be buffaloed by experts and elites. Experts often possess more data than judgment. Elites can become so inbred that they produce hemophiliacs who bleed to death as soon as they are nicked by the real world.”

“Small companies and startups don’t have the time for analytically detached experts. They don’t have the money to subsidize lofty elites, either. The president answers the phone and drives the truck when necessary; everyone on the payroll visibly produces and contributes to bottom-line results or they’re history. But as companies get bigger, they often forget who ‘brung them to the dance’: things like all-hands involvement, egalitarianism, informality, market intimacy, daring, risk, speed, and agility. Policies that emanate from ivory towers often have an adverse impact on the people out in the field who are fighting the wars or bringing in the revenues. Real leaders are vigilant and combative in the face of these trends.”

How General Powell’s leadership lesson is relevant to retail

In today’s retail landscape, AI is the hot topic. The potential for Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning to transform retail operations—both customer-facing and back-end—is undeniable. However, as General Powell warned, we must be cautious of those who speak from an ivory tower, detached from the realities of day-to-day operations.

There’s a saying from the 16th century: “In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king.” This applies in spades when it comes to AI. With so many claiming expertise in this complex and technical field, it’s all too easy to be led astray by someone who may know just a little more than you but presents themselves as the all-knowing expert.

Retailers today face immense pressure to do more with less—to find ways to leverage AI and other technologies to drive faster returns on investment while keeping capital expenditures low. But this pressure can lead to falling for flashy promises or misguided guidance from self-proclaimed “experts” who may not fully grasp the long-term impact on the business.

This is where Powell’s leadership lessons come into play. Small companies and startups excel because they understand the importance of:

• Market intimacy: A deep connection to the realities of their market, their customers, and their competition.
  
• Daring, risk, speed, and agility: The ability to take calculated risks and pivot quickly when necessary.
  
• Informality: Creating an open and collaborative environment that encourages innovative ideas from all levels of the organization.
  
• Egalitarianism: Valuing contributions from every team member, regardless of rank or experience.
  

Smart ideas come from everywhere

I’ve never been a fan of top-down decision-making when it comes to selecting solutions for business challenges. The smartest people aren’t always at the top of the hierarchy; often, they’re scattered throughout the ranks. I’ve learned this lesson the hard way. In my career, one of my biggest mistakes was ignoring the advice of smart people around me who warned me about the risks of a decision I was making. I held onto my choice out of pride, and those risks materialized in ways I could have avoided.

So, my advice for retailers today is simple:

1. Know your market: This means understanding not only your customers but also your competitors, industry trends, and the full scope of service offerings. Product-market fit isn’t just for physical products. It applies to everything, whether you’re selling shoes or AI platforms.
   
2. Be a calculated risk-taker: And be agile enough to adjust when things don’t go according to plan.
   
3. Foster an environment that encourages open conversations from all levels of the organization: The best ideas, innovations, and risk mitigation strategies often come from the most junior employees.
   
4. Ensure that everyone’s opinion is valued: At least in the early stages of decision-making, the most junior person in the room might offer the insight that shifts the entire conversation.
   

Memorial Day is a reminder to lead with purpose

As we reflect on Memorial Day, let’s remember not only those who gave their lives but also the values they fought for: freedom, responsibility, and service. General Colin Powell epitomized those values throughout his career, whether in uniform or as a mentor and leader to those around him.

I hope everyone had a meaningful Memorial Day weekend, filled with gratitude for those who made the ultimate sacrifice. Thank you, General Powell, for your years of service and for the leadership principles that continue to guide us today. Your legacy, and the sacrifices of so many, will never be forgotten.

—

Inspired by leadership rooted in real-world experience? So are we. Let’s connect. Contact us to see how our AI-powered OMS helps modern retailers move with agility, clarity, and confidence.

---